I've been combing through old recipes lately and found one that made me realize that my baking obsession has been going full-tilt for over three years now. While I had always made homemade treats for holidays or special occasions, my baking habit was not the the fever pitched frenzy that it has turned into at this point. At Christmas, I would pull out tried and tested recipes to make Jan’s biscotti or a classic gingerbread recipe from my mom’s old copy of a Southern Living cookbook. Back then I never felt strange pangs in the market when I saw the perfect ingredient, spent (too many) hours reading food blogs and researching recipes, or remade and reworked recipes to the point of making myself (and others) thoroughly sick of the offending baked good.
My descent into baking battiness began with a particular recipe that I spied in Domino Magazine way back in the January 2007 issue. I had always been a shelter magazine junky and would peruse the recipes in the more staid glossies, but the chefs’ creations in those magazines were way too intimidating to me. Domino made their recipes look so much easier and more accessible. When I saw their Meyer lemon cake recipe, it caught my eye and I decided to give it a go.
Let me just say up front that my first foray into untested recipe territory was not a resounding success. I managed to assemble the ingredients into a semblance of the tempting picture in the magazine, but the cake’s consistency was way too dense. I literally felt like I was picking up a brick when I moved the cake from the cooling rack to a plate. If memory and a little more experience serve me correctly, I’d say the brick-like consistency was due to my not knowing how to make a meringue properly and pouring the entire 2 cups of glaze on the cake while still hot from the oven (the cake soaked it up like a sponge). But something magical happened after I applied the candied lemon peel topping and stepped back to appraise my work... the cake actually looked almost cute enough that I could ignore it’s heft (and the fact that it had fallen as flat as a pancake). I began to re-evaluate my effort and started feeling much better about the result in light of its more attractive appearance.
Such is a recurring theme in my life; I’ll often set aside practicality and function in favor of “cute factor”. This explains half the shoes in my closet and a couch that I curse every night when I sit on it. An old, dear friend (Ms. Crawford, I am calling you out on the interweb! I miss you!) and I used to have a saying between us when the going got rough. If one of us were complaining about some perceived slight or everything going to hell in a hand basket, the other would interrupt and remind the complainer, “But you look good!” It was our amalgamation on “showing up is half the battle” and “looking good is the best revenge.”
Sometimes you don’t hit it out of the park on your first attempt but there is some small, redeeming quality that makes you want to keep at it. And I’m still at it 3+ years later, so I decided to revisit the Meyer lemon cake recipe to see if I could improve on my original attempt. My second attempt was still a little on the dense side, even though I now know what soft versus stiff peaks are (I so had no idea the first time) and waited until the cake was thoroughly cool before spooning on the glaze. I don’t think this recipe is ever going to make my “greatest hits list.” In fact, I have another lemon cake recipe that I much prefer but I couldn’t resist giving this one another try. After all, I wouldn’t be writing this blog post today if this cake hadn’t started the addiction.
Meyer Lemon Cake – makes one 9-inch cake
from Domino Magazine
I didn’t change any of the recipe’s ingredients but I did rearrange the instructions a bit. I was so uptight about following every step exactly as listed when I first started baking, I would have been halfway through the recipe before I got to the step on buttering and flouring the cake pan per the original instructions. I spent considerable time and money in pastry school to learn to always read the recipe twice before starting. That, and stopping mid-production to complete a step that should have been done when setting up the mise en place isn’t an efficient use of time. When I re-reviewed the recipe, I noticed other steps that were combined or ordered in a manner that I wouldn’t have found helpful as a novice baker. I hope some other newbie baker will benefit from my tweaks.
Ingredients:
8 T unsalted butter
4 large eggs, separated
1 1/4 c sugar
2/3 c buttermilk
1/3 c Meyer lemon juice
1 T Meyer lemon zest
2 c cake flour
1-1/4 t baking powder
1/4 t salt
Glaze:
1/3 c Meyer lemon juice
1 2/3 c confectioners' sugar
Candied Meyer lemon slices:
2 Meyer lemons
2 c sugar
1. Preheat the oven to 325° F. Butter and sugar or flour a 9-inch cake pan or Bundt pan.
2. Melt butter in saucepan. Set aside to cool.
3. In a large bowl, sift together cake flour, baking powder and salt.
4. In a mixing bowl, using an electric mixer, beat egg yolks with 1 cup of the sugar until thick and light in color, about 2 to 3 minutes. Beat in buttermilk, Meyer lemon juice, and zest.
5. In a separate bowl, beat egg whites with an electric mixer until they hold soft peaks. Then add the remaining 1/4 cup of sugar and continue beating until stiff peaks form.
6. Gently, so you don't deflate the batter, fold half of the flour mixture into egg-yolk mixture, followed by half of the egg white mixture. Repeat with remaining flour and egg white mixtures. Stir approximately 1 cup of the batter into the melted butter. Gently fold butter mixture into the rest of the cake batter. Pour into cake pan and bake for about 50 to 60 minutes or until cake is lightly brown and pulling slightly away from the edge of the pan.
7. While the cake is baking, make the glaze and candied Meyer lemon slices. For the glaze, combine Meyer lemon juice and confectioners' sugar in a saucepan. Heat, stirring occasionally, until sugar is dissolved. Set aside. For the candied slices, cut Meyer lemons width wise, in 1/4 inch slices, and discard end pieces. Remove seeds. In a saucepan, combine 2 cups of water with 2 cups of sugar. Bring to a gentle boil and simmer five minutes. Add lemon slices and simmer about five more minutes, until fruit is soft but not falling apart. With a slotted spoon, remove slices and place on waxed or parchment paper.
8. When the cake is done, cool in the pan for 5 minutes, and then invert onto a cooling rack. With a long toothpick, poke the top of the cake to make about two dozen small deep holes. Slowly spoon the warm glaze over the cake, allowing the glaze to sink in before adding more. Poke extra holes if needed, eventually using all of the glaze. Arrange the candied lemon slices in a random pattern on top. Cool the cake completely and serve.